Wednesday, 11 September 2013

Anime Thoughts: First Genshiken, Now Stella - Am I Thinking Way Too Hard About This Stuff, Or Actually On to Something?

Attack on Titan [ep. 20 - Erwin Smith: 57th Expedition Beyond the Walls, Part 4]
Of course – a spy! That’s why some of the soldiers wouldn’t know everything, or be told conflicting information. And if they think there’s a spy who also has the ability to transform in their ranks, of course they’d bring along something tailored to capture an intelligent Titan. Damnit me, you suspect humans are behind the Titans, how were you not able to think of any of this? OK, yeah, bottom line, none of this stuff about everyone being told Eren was in a different place or the expedition ‘conveniently’ having something for capturing the Female Titan is as suspicious as I was making it out to be. Because I apparently never considered that the people behind the Titans would do something like infiltrate the Survey Corps. I was thinking that the brass knew about the Female Titan already, and was maybe even connected to whoever’s behind the Titans – like this was all part of a plan to make everyone think they were gaining ground when they actually weren’t. Or something, it doesn’t make much sense even to me, especially now. Not sure if the series was actually that good at not making it obvious or if I was just so focused on one possibility I overlooked another, though.

There was also an interesting contrast between deception and trust in these last few episodes. Smith and Levi were asking everyone to take their word that everything was under control, because of the need to fool the person controlling the Female Titan. But they’re in a situation where there’s too much potential for things to go wrong if everyone isn’t on the same page, like how Eren almost transformed because he couldn’t see any other solution, but in hindsight that could’ve seriously jeopardized the actual plan. Only telling everyone the full plan is a bad idea because it means they’ll alert the spy. The need to balance the two is just another one of those ways the show makes it clear that, beneath all the giant-slaying and swinging from wires, these people are in an extremely precarious situation.


Stella Women’s Academy [ep. 8 – Should a Commander be Cold of Heart?]

Well, I was completely off the mark on this one. I suppose I shouldn’t be too surprise they won; OK, there’s no shouldn’t about it – I’m not; the show’s about them, after all. And yeah, they didn’t win, but until Yura ‘fesses up, they think they did.

But still, when you see that there’s other teams made up of people like active members of the Marine Corps, or others who seem like they’d have way more years of experience, not to mention relevant training, you’d think they’d be better than a team of high schoolers. I knew Rin’s team was supposed to be insanely good, but not that they were god-damn ninjas. Seriously, what kind of training do those girls do?

I suppose Rin does have that sneaky side, though. I don’t mean covertly taking out Sono – that’s under-handed, but mostly just bad sportsmanship. I mean her ‘I see what you did there – and I won’t tell anyone’ stealth attack on Yura. I don’t know about you, but I’d wager a guilty conscience trumps the temporary humiliation of being called out right away most of the time.

I was also assuming that the tournament would be a multi-part thing because it lasts long enough, and has so many participants, that each succeeding episode could have had Stella going up against a different team and having to use different strategies each time. Obviously, Rin’s team would be reserved for the final showdown. Except, that’s not what it was actually about. And probably would’ve been kind of repetitive, now that I think about it. Rather, it was the dramatic payoff for the foreshadowing from episode 5, about how Yura can get so wrapped up in the moment that she loses sight of the larger picture. In this case she got so wrapped up in getting even with Rin and proving her wrong that she ended up proving her right. Losing may not have proven her wrong, but cheating to win definitely validated her beliefs.

She’s also kind of a cliché, being the antagonist who’s become so focused on winning it’s become its own purpose. It’s an understandable mindset coming from a culture that places so much value on success and excellence, and sure, winning’s part of anything competitive and very much a goal, but when you think about it, by itself it has no meaning. You won – so what? By itself, all it does is make you feel good about yourself temporarily. It has no meaning in the long run unless your goal is just validating how much better you are than everyone else by continually winning.

And I gotta say, boy is she misguided with the whole ‘airsoft is just like real war – all that matters is winning.’ Because, correct me if I’m wrong, but no functional human being has ever fought a war simply to win. Rather, in a war you’re fighting for something – control over a territory, freedom of various sorts, for or against an ideology, what have you – that the other side opposes strongly enough that you need to take it through force. Sure, you want to win, but that’s only because winning is how you achieve your goal. It’s just a means to an end, not the end itself. Obviously, this is a simplification, but I think the bigger point speaks for itself.

It looks more and more like Sono really does have the right of it. Airsoft isn’t about winning, it’s a way of learning things about yourself and even gaining an appreciation for the gravity of real violence. At least, that’s what it means to her, and by giving a meaning to why she plays, she actually understands competitiveness way more than Rin, as much as the latter seems to think otherwise. So do the other girls, for that matter, when they let slip that they aren’t having fun and that’s hurting the experience. This may just be a fun little show about girls playing airsoft on the surface, but with things like this it does feel like its trying to make a point about competition and what you can learn from it. And that guns and violence should be taken seriously, even when you’re just playing a game for fun.


The Eccentric Family [ep. 8 – The Day of Dad’s Departure]

Well, unless Kaisei was told to start coming on to Yajiro so he’d fall for her, it doesn’t look like Soichiro’s death was arranged or set up by anyone, based on what we saw this episode. Rather, it looks like it’s exactly what he saw it as going to it, and what the general tanuki philosophy towards hot-potting can be summed up as – shit happens – and those who stand to benefit from him being out of the picture didn’t arrange it, they’re just moving to take advantage of it. It puts this series in a new light – it’s not a mystery about why someone was murdered but rather his family coming to terms with their loss and learning to understand those who were responsible for it, or are trying to profit from it. Granted the next episode looks like it’ll be about Kaisei, who’s the reason Yajiro and his father went drinking in the first place, that will probably shine a new light on things and may through that reveal that there is a conspiracy, but it doesn’t look like that’s gonna happen. Which I’ve gotta say, I like. It’s not like ‘a family coping with loss’ has never been done before, but there aren’t too many anime like that, at least not to my knowledge, so it’s nice to see.

No comments:

Post a Comment